I consider myself somewhat environmentally conscious and definitely budget-conscious, which is why I don’t naturally relate to the idea of overconsumption. It’s also why my recent actions surprised me, and why I’m a bit embarrassed to share this story. A few weeks ago, we decided to rearrange the furniture in our family room. After doing so, we sat about five feet farther from the TV. This made our 48-inch TV feel pretty small. This problem was easy to solve. We bought a bigger TV. We found a 55-inch art TV on sale.
Looking back, it’s surprising how quickly I went from “the TV feels small” to “let’s buy a bigger one.” The idea felt like my own, but I wonder how much I’ve learned to see every inconvenience as something a purchase can fix. This just goes to show how difficult it is not to buy into the messaging that we can solve every inconvenience with a purchase.
This experience left me thinking about how the current consumer culture started, what it’s doing to our world and what we can do about it. Here’s what I found out.
What is overconsumption?
By the early 1970s, humanity was using resources faster than the Earth could regenerate them. In 2026, according to the Global Footprint Network, we need 1.73 Earths to sustain our level of natural resource consumption. Overconsumption means taking more from the planet than what can be regenerated.
The history of consumption
In the early 1900s, people typically only bought what they needed. Advertising was an explanation of the facts about a product or service. In the 1920s, Edward Bernays, Sigmund Freud’s nephew, taught American corporations that they could make people want things that they didn’t need by appealing to their inner selfish desires – their emotions.
Bernays’ most famous advertising campaign was used to persuade women to smoke. In 1929, women typically did not smoke. Cigarette companies realized that if they could appeal to women, they could double their sales. Bernays published pictures of women smoking and called the cigarettes “torches of freedom.” Bernays made women believe that cigarettes would make them more independent and powerful. While this was totally irrational, it did make women feel more independent.
What drives overconsumption?
This change in advertising, now appealing to people’s emotions, was a significant contributor to increased consumption. Now we sometimes shop to feel better, because we believe it will help us fit in, because last year’s clothes are no longer cool, or even just because things are cheap. Most recently, we also shop because it only takes a few clicks and we can do it any time of day or night. I can’t help but wonder – are all of these wants actually our own?
Social media keeps us wanting more
On social media, ads and influencers constantly connect products with a better version of our lives.
I’m always surprised by the many beauty products that my daughter has needed to buy since she has had a job and money to spend. I remember her announcing one day that she needed eyelash serum. I thought, “What the heck is eyelash serum?” She already has beautiful lashes, but after watching those Instagram reels, she started to feel like they weren’t good enough.
The impact of overconsumption on our thoughts and dreams
It is very common to take the messages we’re bombarded with every day and assume that those messages are presenting us with our own thoughts and dreams. We start to believe that we need a bigger house like our friends and a better wardrobe like everyone on Instagram, without questioning where these ideas came from. How often do we actually stop and think about what we really want and question if those wants are really ours?
The impact of overconsumption on our wallet
The problem with constantly being fed messages about what will make our lives better is that we can end up overspending on things that don’t actually make our lives better. Then, when we want money for something that will truly bring us joy, we may not have it. It can also mean putting purchases on a credit card when we can’t pay off the balance. Then we have debt payments we can’t afford, and the vicious cycle can spiral downward.
We may find ourselves having to work more to pay the bills, when what we really want is more time with family and friends. When we want to save for our dream vacation, we realize that all those Amazon and Skip the Dishes buys have really added up.
What can we do about overconsumption?
Understanding how advertising can shape our thoughts can give us more agency to question those messages and make our own choices.
- Be intentional about the messages you let into your brain. Limit your social media time and unfollow accounts that are feeding your overconsumption. Unsubscribe from emails that make you want to shop. For me, this meant unsubscribing from emails from my favourite clothing retailers.
- Notice what you already have. Keep a gratitude journal and pay attention to what feels like enough. After we moved to a more expensive area and had to downsize our house, I spent a lot of time looking at realtor.ca for a nicer house. Constantly looking for more made me feel less content with what I had. I blocked realtor.ca for a few years to help me appreciate what I already had.
- Design the life you want. Reflect on your values and what you want your life to look like. Do you want more time with family and friends? More travel, creativity, peace of mind? When you’re clear about what matters most to you, it’s easier to decide what purchases make sense and which ones don’t.
- Have a plan to get to where you want to go. Yes, that means a budget. Know what you can afford to spend in areas of life that you may be tempted to overconsume. Maybe it’s clothes, random stuff from Amazon, technology or bigger stuff like vehicles or a house. Decide in advance what you can spend while still affording the things that are most important to you.
Taking back our choices
Before buying our new television, I asked Google how large a TV should be if it is 15 feet from its viewers. It told me it should be 83 to 98 inches or larger. I was shocked. That is huge! Those are the messages that we are being fed all the time: the bigger the better, the more the better. This time, at least, I decided for myself what was big enough.
We can start questioning those messages and making more deliberate choices about what we buy. Choosing what is enough for us can leave more room in our budgets for what matters and reduce the demands we place on the planet.
If overconsumption has put you in a difficult financial place and you need help to change that, reach out. Our credit counsellors are here to help.







